Time for Asking Why

Tommy Sands
Language: English

Related Songs

The Convict of Clonmel
(The Clancy Brothers)
The Music Of Healing
(Tommy Sands)
The Winds Are Singing Freedom
(Tommy Makem)

Album "Let the Circle Be Wide"

Canzone dedicata a Mychal Judge, prete cattolico, cappellano dei vigili del fuoco di New York, morto nell'attentato dell'11 settembre 2001

Judge era di origini irlandesi e più volte si era recato in Irlanda lavorando in favore del processo di pace. Così Tommy Sands introduce la sua canzone:

"I often think of Fr Mychal Judge. He was chaplain in the New York Fire Brigade and the first official victim in the murderous events of 9/11. I had met Mychal several times when he came to Ireland to help out with our Peace Process. I thought it sadly ironic that the death of someone who had spent his entire life saving innocent lives could be somehow used as an excuse for more innocents to die.

This song is for America not against America. It is directed, however, towards a relatively small group of individuals who come to power from time to time, wrap themselves in stars and stripes and then proceed to behave in the most unjust and shamefully anti American way."
I remember September turning on the TV
The horror and sorrow I could not believe
Murder and burning and insanity
Once more we sat watching and grieving
And leaders were asking just how could it be
From where and just who did this terrible deed
But no one asked why is such hatred conceived
Or where is the lesson for learning

It's time for asking why

I think about all those brave firemen who died
Who gave their last breath just to save human life
How could such death somehow rationalise
More murder and burning and killing
And who are the terrorists you're searching for
Your leaflet came down from an aircraft of war
And it lay on a child you left blinded and scarred
In a country long broken and bleeding

It's time for asking why

Where is your freedom please say it's not true
Do answers come down from a B52
Just do as I say but don't do as I do
Is this the new order you're leading
And how many countries did you overthrow
Do you mock the democracy you can't control
Where is your conscience and where is your soul
When you pray to God bless America

It's time for asking why

A people excluded will say it's not fair
There's enough to go round so why don't you share
You're preaching equality yet you go there
And grab all their food from the table
Is it hunger for power that's blinding your sights
Does it block out the stars does it tear up the stripes
Denying your justice, your freedom, your rights
Who is betraying America
It's time for asking why

I dream that America still has a dream
When empires will pass and children will sing
Of Seeger and Guthrie and good Martin King
A song of peace to all nations
God bless America muster her power
To care for her sick to look after her poor
Bring peace to her children not send them to war
And never be fearful to question.

Contributed by Alessandro - 2009/9/18 - 18:49

Main Page

Please report any error in lyrics or commentaries to

Note for non-Italian users: Sorry, though the interface of this website is translated into English, most commentaries and biographies are in Italian and/or in other languages like French, German, Spanish, Russian etc.

hosted by